The Definite Article
Moderators: Philip Whiteman, George, Dave Cox
The Definite Article
I have always been aware of being a member of "The Beacon" and have heard other members referring to other cycling clubs such as "The Stourbridge". This way of expressing the name of ones club appears peculiar to cycling. Other sports clubs I played for did not refer to themselves in this manner. I played hockey for "Blossomfield" in Solihull, rather than "The Blossomfield", for instance. Last night, I watched the quaintly enthusiastic Alf Engers documentary at The MAC and was further intrigued by this quirk of nomenclature, as Alf referred to "The Barnet" and "The Saracen". Could one our more learned members tell me more about this?
- Andy Terry
- Posts: 904
- Joined: 20 Nov 2006 14:27
- Real Name:
- Location: Bromsgrove, Worcs
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
- petemarshall
- Posts: 663
- Joined: 17 Jan 2014 16:40
- Real Name: Pete Marshall
- Location: Stourbridge
It's a class thing. Working class sports, cycling football use "the".
Posh sports don't
I supported the Blues at football but followed Warwickshire at cricket.
Now cycling is moving up the British class system I expect to be a member of Beacon soon and follow Birmingham City (although if the Blues even manage to become a middle class team the world will truly be turned upside down.
Posh fans of the V***a ,mainly from Sutton Coldfield have always failed to use the the. Some even using the alternate name of West Ham United.
Posh sports don't
I supported the Blues at football but followed Warwickshire at cricket.
Now cycling is moving up the British class system I expect to be a member of Beacon soon and follow Birmingham City (although if the Blues even manage to become a middle class team the world will truly be turned upside down.
Posh fans of the V***a ,mainly from Sutton Coldfield have always failed to use the the. Some even using the alternate name of West Ham United.
I always refer to the them Lions as 'the Villa' also the blues and the Albion
That's because I'm lower class, I look up to him but not as much as i look up to him as he is upper class.
Doesn't the 'The' take the place of the first word ie 'The Villa' but Aston Villa,so 'the Beacon but Beacon Roads ,not sure that that really works .anyway one would only ever say Chelsea because they are like really posh
Yar
That's because I'm lower class, I look up to him but not as much as i look up to him as he is upper class.
Doesn't the 'The' take the place of the first word ie 'The Villa' but Aston Villa,so 'the Beacon but Beacon Roads ,not sure that that really works .anyway one would only ever say Chelsea because they are like really posh
Yar
Sorry, I'm going to disagree with most of you in one way or another.
It isn't exclusive to cycling; it isn't even exclusive to sport; it isn't a class thing and there is no clear grammatical reason that I know of why one should use an article or not use an article.
As others have said, it's very common in football too. Everyone at school prefixed local club names with 'the', and I still do so. "Up the Villa" is a very old exhortation that lives on in the widely used hashtag #UTV. However, at no point in my life has the definite article been comfortably applicable to all football club names: you would often hear people say "the City" (not only when speaking about the Blues) and you might occasionally hear someone say "the Spurs", but never "the United" or "the Everton". If you look at formal documents, I'm fairly sure a lot of club names include an article ("Article 1. The company shall be called the Warwickshire County Anysport Club"), and in common parlance you'll hear phrases such as "the Warwicks", "the Wigornians" etc. I'm fairly sure I have ancient tickets that have T&Cs that include articles.
In my line of work, I write and translate for a lot of companies, foundations, professional associations and what-have-you. Many of them have 'house styles': they want you to consistently write certain things in certain ways. Many of them want to be referred to as "the XYZ Foundation" and just as many of them opt for "XYZ Foundation". There is no rhyme or reason to it... unless perhaps a vague sense that "the XYZ Foundation" sounds a tiny bit more solid and formal and "XYZ Foundation" a tiny bit more dynamic and approachable.
It isn't exclusive to cycling; it isn't even exclusive to sport; it isn't a class thing and there is no clear grammatical reason that I know of why one should use an article or not use an article.
As others have said, it's very common in football too. Everyone at school prefixed local club names with 'the', and I still do so. "Up the Villa" is a very old exhortation that lives on in the widely used hashtag #UTV. However, at no point in my life has the definite article been comfortably applicable to all football club names: you would often hear people say "the City" (not only when speaking about the Blues) and you might occasionally hear someone say "the Spurs", but never "the United" or "the Everton". If you look at formal documents, I'm fairly sure a lot of club names include an article ("Article 1. The company shall be called the Warwickshire County Anysport Club"), and in common parlance you'll hear phrases such as "the Warwicks", "the Wigornians" etc. I'm fairly sure I have ancient tickets that have T&Cs that include articles.
In my line of work, I write and translate for a lot of companies, foundations, professional associations and what-have-you. Many of them have 'house styles': they want you to consistently write certain things in certain ways. Many of them want to be referred to as "the XYZ Foundation" and just as many of them opt for "XYZ Foundation". There is no rhyme or reason to it... unless perhaps a vague sense that "the XYZ Foundation" sounds a tiny bit more solid and formal and "XYZ Foundation" a tiny bit more dynamic and approachable.
-
- Posts: 285
- Joined: 06 Jun 2010 15:47
- Real Name: Nic Vipond
- Location: Birmingham
There is much confusion about that, Tim. I have asked (near-)founder members and generally found their responses vague or otherwise unsatisfactory.Tim wrote:Is this a good time to ask what is possibly a very stupid question? Why is it roads and not road in Beacon Roads Cycling Club?!
The best explanation I've heard, or at least the one that best caters for my desire for there to be a satisfactory explanation, is that the club was originally based on the roads over and around Beacon Hill.
-
- Posts: 1119
- Joined: 31 Dec 2011 13:48
- Real Name:
- Location: Harborne
There's also Walsall Roads, so it's not just the Beacon that uses the plural. Can anyone think of any clubs that you wouldn't use "the" for? Although it's not unique to cycling that the definite article can sometimes be used, I can't think of any other sports where it can be applied to all clubs (I had an American girlfriend for a while who insisted on "the Rangers" and "the Celtic", which is clearly wrong).
Hmmm... I am never particularly swayed by arguments around class. If we look at football, a resolutely working class game, clubs with "County" in their name are always "County" and never "The County", the latter I reckon is a more middle class way of expressing it. Also, Nottingham Forest is always "Forest" and not "The Forest". And I can say with some amount of authority that it is "Spurs" and not "The Spurs" but in my experience of West Midlands teams, I think "Villa" and "The Villa" are interchangeable. My wife would say she supports "Blues" but if visiting a home game at St Andrews would be "going down The Blues" whereas "The Albion" is always "The Albion". And Wolves are never "The Wolves" but who really cares about them?
So I would contend that this style is fairly unique to cycling, if we look at Andy's response above, referring to "The Bromsgrove". It must be just me that this sounds strange to.
So I would contend that this style is fairly unique to cycling, if we look at Andy's response above, referring to "The Bromsgrove". It must be just me that this sounds strange to.
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
I must admit that I have only ever referred to them as Bromsgrove Olympic, without the definite article. As for 'The Stourbridge', that could cause confusion given that there are three clubs that bear Stourbridge somewhere within their club title.toby wrote: So I would contend that this style is fairly unique to cycling, if we look at Andy's response above, referring to "The Bromsgrove". It must be just me that this sounds strange to.
- petemarshall
- Posts: 663
- Joined: 17 Jan 2014 16:40
- Real Name: Pete Marshall
- Location: Stourbridge
It must be a slow night on telly How many times can you watch the Villa's goal from yesterday. just to confuse things Peterborough United have always been called 'the Posh'. Hysterical when the Mrs Beckham tried to stop them using it , or was that an just an urban myth .
Some motorcycle clubs/Gangs are known as The Wolverhampton the 69 and the Coventry (2 wheel thing ?)
I think it assumes that every one knows the full name
I guess in the end its what sounds good or right
Some motorcycle clubs/Gangs are known as The Wolverhampton the 69 and the Coventry (2 wheel thing ?)
I think it assumes that every one knows the full name
I guess in the end its what sounds good or right
It seems to work for most clubs, although not sure it would work for all eg 'Solihull CC'...don't hear anyone referring to them as 'The Solihull'laurence_cooley wrote:There's also Walsall Roads, so it's not just the Beacon that uses the plural. Can anyone think of any clubs that you wouldn't use "the" for?
John - The example from the Alf Engers documentary I mentioned, The Barnet, are/were in North London/South Herts. An area where I have family.John wrote:It's partly a local dialect thing to - in Birmingham lots of things are prefixed with the definite article such as the Hagley Road, or the Pershore Road.
The clubs where I grew up were never prefixed and were just referred to by name, and I still don't refer to this club as The Beacon.
I also referred to his mention of The Saracen. I intend to find out whether this is the Saracen Road Club, on our doorstep.
If you do not refer to the club as "The Beacon", you need to start