Getting taken up the pass
Moderators: Philip Whiteman, Andy Terry
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
Getting taken up the pass
Hello all. My uncle has invited me up to the Lake District in July to have a ride up some of the big passes including Hard Knott and Wrynose. Pretty fearsome climbs. Given that I can't borrow John Hitchcock's legs for the duration, I suspect that I will need to gear down a bit from my current low of 34-27. My question is, would I be better off fitting a triple chainset (meaning a new shifter as well), or fitting a mountain bike block on the back? Are there any technical difficulties with either solution?
Or should I simply get out my walking boots and leave the bike at home?
Or should I simply get out my walking boots and leave the bike at home?
Graham
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
I done this a few years ago on a normal triple. It could probably be done with a 38/28 providing you keep to the outside of the curves. But a road triple would be sufficient.
The thing you have be aware of is braking. The steep descents on dry and warm conditions may cause the blocks and rims to run hot. When I rode this route some years ago, I had to dismount and walk off Hardnott.
The thing you have be aware of is braking. The steep descents on dry and warm conditions may cause the blocks and rims to run hot. When I rode this route some years ago, I had to dismount and walk off Hardnott.
- Andy Terry
- Posts: 904
- Joined: 20 Nov 2006 14:27
- Real Name:
- Location: Bromsgrove, Worcs
I'm not sure what the risks are so I hesitate suggesting you 'try this at home' but I think you can sometimes get away with being outside spec's. For a couple of specific hilly audaxes I used a cassette including a 32 sprocket with a Shimano rear derailleur for which the quoted max was 27 I think, maybe 28. I could see why it wasn't meant to be (just a chains width gap between largest sprocket and top jockey) but on the basis that I was only going to use it a few times on two rides and I was never going to use the large-large combo I decided to take a chance and it worked out fine. Mind you, I also had a triple chainset, I guess with a compact double you'd have to make more of a conscious effort never to use large-large.
edit - if you decide you don't want to risk it, it might be cheaper & easier to fit a rear derailleur with a longer cage than to change the chain set and front derailleur.
edit - if you decide you don't want to risk it, it might be cheaper & easier to fit a rear derailleur with a longer cage than to change the chain set and front derailleur.
Eat cake before you're hungry
It was many years ago now but I recall tackling Hardknott and Wrynose with an ordinary double chainset and a fairly ordinary cassette such as 12-27 or it may only have been 12-25.
I didn't manage to ride up them but I don't think I had to walk very far. People seem to forget that walking is always an option. Those hills are stupidly steep - it's no shame to walk and it's only the sportive MAMILs who seem to think their cycling prowess is proved by riding up hills like that.
Personally I'd take walking boots to the Lake District. Riding in that terrain holds no appeal for me at all.
Ruth
I didn't manage to ride up them but I don't think I had to walk very far. People seem to forget that walking is always an option. Those hills are stupidly steep - it's no shame to walk and it's only the sportive MAMILs who seem to think their cycling prowess is proved by riding up hills like that.
Personally I'd take walking boots to the Lake District. Riding in that terrain holds no appeal for me at all.
Ruth
-
- Posts: 90
- Joined: 21 Nov 2006 15:55
- Real Name: Rod Goodfellow
- Location: Cranage,Holmes Chapel,Cheshire,UK or Lake Wales,Florida
I've done both hills both ways on 42x28 when I was only middle aged.However on one occasion whilst riding to work at Sellafield with loaded panniers I fell off up the west side of Wrynose as it was difficult to steer and balance when the front wheel lifts off the road despite using a 125mm stem.It's steeper than 1in 3 on the inside of the hairpins which you may be forced into by oncoming traffic
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
Thanks for the replies. I already have a long cage rear derailleur, so I think I can get away with a 32 sprocket. I'd prefer to go this way if possible because I don't want to spend out on a triple chainset, shifter and front mech when I will hardly ever use them. Just wanted to check whether there were any technical issues I might not have thought of.
Ruth - you're right of course, I don't want to get too macho about getting up big hills, but even if I walk some of the biggies, lower gears will make the rest of the ride more enjoyable.
Ruth - you're right of course, I don't want to get too macho about getting up big hills, but even if I walk some of the biggies, lower gears will make the rest of the ride more enjoyable.
Graham
I have ridden them both two up on a motorbike, scared the living daylights out of me!!
In fact, one horror story that wil remain with me for ever. There were a large group of us doing a coast to coast run, and most of us were riding BMW bikes, which have servo assisted brakes.
Plus most of us were riding two up and also with panniers loaded with luggage etc
We came to one of the many steeply banked and upward facing hairpin bends, remembering that you have to take the outside route as the inner section of the hairpin is just to steep to ascend.
My friend (who was also riding two up and with luggage) managed to stall just after the hairpin, and because the engine had stalled he consquently had NO brakes!
The combined weight of the bike and no servo assistance resulted in them rollng backwards towards the edge. He was shouting (screaming) to his wife on the back to bail out before the bike dropped over the edge!
They contined to roll back a few feet unable to stop, then he just had to make the awful decision to literally drop the bike on its side otherwise it was going over the edge.
But this forced everyone else to stop on the steepest part of the climb, utter carnage!!
In fact, one horror story that wil remain with me for ever. There were a large group of us doing a coast to coast run, and most of us were riding BMW bikes, which have servo assisted brakes.
Plus most of us were riding two up and also with panniers loaded with luggage etc
We came to one of the many steeply banked and upward facing hairpin bends, remembering that you have to take the outside route as the inner section of the hairpin is just to steep to ascend.
My friend (who was also riding two up and with luggage) managed to stall just after the hairpin, and because the engine had stalled he consquently had NO brakes!
The combined weight of the bike and no servo assistance resulted in them rollng backwards towards the edge. He was shouting (screaming) to his wife on the back to bail out before the bike dropped over the edge!
They contined to roll back a few feet unable to stop, then he just had to make the awful decision to literally drop the bike on its side otherwise it was going over the edge.
But this forced everyone else to stop on the steepest part of the climb, utter carnage!!
"You only need two tools: WD40 and duct tape. If it doesn't move and it should, use WD40. If it moves and it shouldn't, use duct tape"
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
Right, stage two - I've purchased a mountain bike cassette, 11-32 9 speed, seems to fit nicely and the rear mech can cope with it (just); but it is taking the place of a 10-speed cassette, and so I have a 10-speed shifter. So... is it possible to adjust cable/stop screws etc so the shifter will work with a nine-speed cassette, or do I need a 9-speed shifter?
And while I'm at it, will the current 10-speed chain be okay, given that this is only for a couple of rides, or should I purchase a 9-speed chain as well?
Thanks again
And while I'm at it, will the current 10-speed chain be okay, given that this is only for a couple of rides, or should I purchase a 9-speed chain as well?
Thanks again
Graham
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
I am pretty certain that is correct.Philip Whiteman wrote:I think a 10sp chain will be too narrow for a 9sp cassette.
Plus, I'm thinking that the spacing is narrower on the 10sp cassette than on the 9sp cassette, which would suggest that the 10sp shifters "may" not work with a 9sp cassette?
"You only need two tools: WD40 and duct tape. If it doesn't move and it should, use WD40. If it moves and it shouldn't, use duct tape"
If we're talking shimano, I believe the amount of pull is the same on 9 & 10 speed sti's so the shifters should be fine.
I'm pretty sure that you need a 9sp chain for a 9sp cassette though.
edit - the chain is narrower and the sprockets thinner but the spacing is the same.
I'm pretty sure that you need a 9sp chain for a 9sp cassette though.
edit - the chain is narrower and the sprockets thinner but the spacing is the same.
Eat cake before you're hungry
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
You can use a 10 speed chain on a 9 speed cassette but not the other way round as the wider 9 speed chains will not sit properly on the narrower 10 speed cassette !
The problem you have is that the 10 speed shifter is set to the 10 speed cassette spacing (and you cannot adjust this) so will not be compatible with the 9 speed.
Its either a 9 speed shifter or look for a large 10 speed cassette. The largest one I have is a 11-28 which when used with a compac will get you up any hill without too much trouble.
The problem you have is that the 10 speed shifter is set to the 10 speed cassette spacing (and you cannot adjust this) so will not be compatible with the 9 speed.
Its either a 9 speed shifter or look for a large 10 speed cassette. The largest one I have is a 11-28 which when used with a compac will get you up any hill without too much trouble.
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
Thanks again everyone. It is all Shimano. I'll experiment with the current shifter, but if it doesn't work, I think I'll take Phil's advice and make the best of the current setup. Swapping cassettes and chain is not much bother/expense, but more faffing around than that is probably not worth it. (Apart from the fun of bike tinkering )
Graham
I don't know because I have never tried it, but personally I would question that because 10sp works on a very close tolerance?CakeStop wrote:I've read elsewhere that you can get away with a difference of up to 0.6mm for the shifting to still work OK.
I have just measured a Ultegra 9sp cassette and a 10sp Ultegra cassette with my vernier. The 9sp is 36.75 mm while the 10sp is 37.85 mm, outer edge to outer edge.
So 1.1 mm difference between the two, that would suggest that it wouldn't work?
But Phil is right, to save all the hassle and expense, walk up the hills its a lot easier!!
"You only need two tools: WD40 and duct tape. If it doesn't move and it should, use WD40. If it moves and it shouldn't, use duct tape"
No, that's the difference across the complete cassette. Tolerance of 0.6mm is sprocket centre - spocket centre. This tolerance is what allows some people to mix campag & shimano in certain combinations.
It'd be quicker to change the cassette & chain and see if it works than to theorise about it.
It'd be quicker to change the cassette & chain and see if it works than to theorise about it.
Eat cake before you're hungry
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
Here are my memories on the pass:
West to East
Hardnott to Cockley Beck - the first part of the climb, approx 100m from the Brotherilkeld telephone box is ruddy hard. It eases off and is quite rideable until you reach two nasty switchbacks just before the fort but can ridden on the outside. The insides are 1:3. The gradient eases but remains steep until the final steeper pulls onto the summit. The decent is nasty with many switchbacks and needs to ridden with extreme care.
Cockley Beck to Wrynose - a nice gradual ascent start for most part but it steepens towards the top with some switch backs. Not as bad as Hardnott but your legs will hurt by this stage. A steep descent but not as problematic as Hardott. Care still needs to be taken.
East to West
A long hard pull to the top of Wrynose. If you are feeling strong on normal gears then it is just about possible.
The ascent from Cockley Beck to the top of Hardnott is probably the worst of all climbs over these passes. Even with MTB gearing it would be a challenge and requires a large degree of stamina.
Pillocks
Descending car drivers do not respect ascending cyclists so be prepared. Plus some car drivers are incompetent at handling their vehicles when using this route.
Another hazard comes in the form of the road through Little Langdale to the foot Wrynose Farm. It is winding, narrow and the bends are often blind, so take care.
Other than that, it is a lovely route and you will enjoy it if only for the view.
West to East
Hardnott to Cockley Beck - the first part of the climb, approx 100m from the Brotherilkeld telephone box is ruddy hard. It eases off and is quite rideable until you reach two nasty switchbacks just before the fort but can ridden on the outside. The insides are 1:3. The gradient eases but remains steep until the final steeper pulls onto the summit. The decent is nasty with many switchbacks and needs to ridden with extreme care.
Cockley Beck to Wrynose - a nice gradual ascent start for most part but it steepens towards the top with some switch backs. Not as bad as Hardnott but your legs will hurt by this stage. A steep descent but not as problematic as Hardott. Care still needs to be taken.
East to West
A long hard pull to the top of Wrynose. If you are feeling strong on normal gears then it is just about possible.
The ascent from Cockley Beck to the top of Hardnott is probably the worst of all climbs over these passes. Even with MTB gearing it would be a challenge and requires a large degree of stamina.
Pillocks
Descending car drivers do not respect ascending cyclists so be prepared. Plus some car drivers are incompetent at handling their vehicles when using this route.
Another hazard comes in the form of the road through Little Langdale to the foot Wrynose Farm. It is winding, narrow and the bends are often blind, so take care.
Other than that, it is a lovely route and you will enjoy it if only for the view.
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
Final word on this, at the risk of being boring - found a simple and elegant solution on Sheldon Brown: http://www.sheldonbrown.com/derailer-ad ... #alternate
Small adjustment to the cable routing increases the pull from the shifter, effectively lining up a ten-speed shifter with a nine speed cassette (with one extra "useless" click at the end of the sequence). So all I have to do is swap the cassette and re-route the cable. It's literally a ten-minute job, and it seems to work fine. Ten-speed chain seems ok too. Sorted.
Small adjustment to the cable routing increases the pull from the shifter, effectively lining up a ten-speed shifter with a nine speed cassette (with one extra "useless" click at the end of the sequence). So all I have to do is swap the cassette and re-route the cable. It's literally a ten-minute job, and it seems to work fine. Ten-speed chain seems ok too. Sorted.
Graham
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
- GrahamGamblin
- Posts: 136
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008 15:39
- Real Name:
- Location: Stirchley