Water Proof Jacket Advice Required
Moderators: Philip Whiteman, Andy Terry
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
Water Proof Jacket Advice Required
I wish to purchase a new waterproof jacket that is actually waterproof, packable into a rear jersey pocket and breathable.
Does anyone have positive experiences of such a jacket, please?
Does anyone have positive experiences of such a jacket, please?
Re: Water Proof Jacket Advice Required
Phil, as far as I'm aware, the marketing people employed by clothing companies are the only people who believe that such things actually exist.Philip Whiteman wrote: ... a jacket that is actually waterproof, packable into a rear jersey pocket and breathable.
There's a review on Bike Radar:
www.bikeradar.com/road/gear/article/bes ... ets-33565/
I've got the Sportful Hot Pack shown, which is really versatile and keeps the elements out to a degree, but it's by no means waterproof.
www.bikeradar.com/road/gear/article/bes ... ets-33565/
I've got the Sportful Hot Pack shown, which is really versatile and keeps the elements out to a degree, but it's by no means waterproof.
Barry has one of these...
http://www.evanscycles.com/products/gor ... 1#features
Looks like you could scrunch it up into a pocket and I recall him telling me it was very waterproof (as long as it's proofed I guess!) and so breathable he was cold (but dry).
Depends how much you want to spend, and whether you want a soft or hard shell. I prefer the Endura eVent stuff myself but it doesn't pack very well (have a waterproof gilet instead).
http://www.evanscycles.com/products/gor ... 1#features
Looks like you could scrunch it up into a pocket and I recall him telling me it was very waterproof (as long as it's proofed I guess!) and so breathable he was cold (but dry).
Depends how much you want to spend, and whether you want a soft or hard shell. I prefer the Endura eVent stuff myself but it doesn't pack very well (have a waterproof gilet instead).
I have yet to find a waterproof shell that is actually 100% waterproof. I have been buying waterproofs for mountaineering for 25+ years and all have been very disappointing; they are not as waterproof or as breathable as claimed by the manufacturers in their marketing BS, and none to date have done what it says on the tin.
I don't have a cycle waterproof as such, but carry a Rab Momentum if it looks like rain. It is lightweight at about 360g but too bulky to go in a jersey pocket. It's made from Event fabric which I think is better than Goretex, but needs regular proofing to stay reasonably (never 100%) waterproof. It is not that breathable and if cycling hard I will be as wet from perspiration as from the rain. I have found that Event is not as hard wearing as Goretex and will rip much easier.
In fact in summer conditions I normally just get wet, or if cooler wear Pertex (Rab Vapor-rise), which although not waterproof is 100% windproof and breathable and allows one to dry completely between showers. Overall I seem to be drier in Pertex than in so called waterproofs.
One that recently caught my eye is Rab's Kinetic jacket. Very light at 230g and made from Pertex Shield plus. No experience of it myself, but is supposed to be waterproof as well as fully breathable. I may try it next, but it is around £120. I want one that I can walk, climb or cycle in and this ticks the boxes, and has a large enough hood to accommodate a helmet.
http://rab.uk.com/products/mens-clothin ... acket.html
http://www.adventuretravelmagazine.co.u ... acket-p110
I don't have a cycle waterproof as such, but carry a Rab Momentum if it looks like rain. It is lightweight at about 360g but too bulky to go in a jersey pocket. It's made from Event fabric which I think is better than Goretex, but needs regular proofing to stay reasonably (never 100%) waterproof. It is not that breathable and if cycling hard I will be as wet from perspiration as from the rain. I have found that Event is not as hard wearing as Goretex and will rip much easier.
In fact in summer conditions I normally just get wet, or if cooler wear Pertex (Rab Vapor-rise), which although not waterproof is 100% windproof and breathable and allows one to dry completely between showers. Overall I seem to be drier in Pertex than in so called waterproofs.
One that recently caught my eye is Rab's Kinetic jacket. Very light at 230g and made from Pertex Shield plus. No experience of it myself, but is supposed to be waterproof as well as fully breathable. I may try it next, but it is around £120. I want one that I can walk, climb or cycle in and this ticks the boxes, and has a large enough hood to accommodate a helmet.
http://rab.uk.com/products/mens-clothin ... acket.html
http://www.adventuretravelmagazine.co.u ... acket-p110
I have a Gore Gore-Tex Pac Jac, and yes it is waterproof and it was expensive, just over a £100 I seem to recall. As the name suggests, it does pack down to fit in your back pocket and I would consider to be okay.
However, you do sweat like a dog in it if you start riding moderately hard or you are climbing as it has no vents at all. So what you gain in one area you lose out in another.
It is only a single skin layer jacket, which is why it packs down so small and if you are not wearing a long sleeve top or arm warmers then it does tend to stick to your bare skin making it rather unpleasant to ride in for any length of time.
But, IMHO it is good to carry with you if nothing else to keep the wind chill at bay should you need to stop for any length of time.
Over the years I have had a whole host of differant 'packable' waterproof jackets, and to be honest none have ever met my expectations.
However, you do sweat like a dog in it if you start riding moderately hard or you are climbing as it has no vents at all. So what you gain in one area you lose out in another.
It is only a single skin layer jacket, which is why it packs down so small and if you are not wearing a long sleeve top or arm warmers then it does tend to stick to your bare skin making it rather unpleasant to ride in for any length of time.
But, IMHO it is good to carry with you if nothing else to keep the wind chill at bay should you need to stop for any length of time.
Over the years I have had a whole host of differant 'packable' waterproof jackets, and to be honest none have ever met my expectations.
"You only need two tools: WD40 and duct tape. If it doesn't move and it should, use WD40. If it moves and it shouldn't, use duct tape"
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
Thanks all. I have opted for a GORE jacket although not the model used by Barry - although I may return swap to that model if my ordered garment is not suitable.
I have generally been satisfied with my wet weather gear for mountain walking where plenty of options are available. Yet cycling does not appear to have mastered this technology yet. Perhaps the money is not their for manufacturers.
My preferred materials have always been e-Vent and Paramo Analogy. Nothing packable is produced in the former and I know by experimentation that Paramo is next to useless when cycling and certainly not practical in summer conditions.
Perhaps I could replicated the attire worn by a rather odd character on campus, who wears a wetsuit whilst cycling.
I have generally been satisfied with my wet weather gear for mountain walking where plenty of options are available. Yet cycling does not appear to have mastered this technology yet. Perhaps the money is not their for manufacturers.
My preferred materials have always been e-Vent and Paramo Analogy. Nothing packable is produced in the former and I know by experimentation that Paramo is next to useless when cycling and certainly not practical in summer conditions.
Perhaps I could replicated the attire worn by a rather odd character on campus, who wears a wetsuit whilst cycling.
- Philip Whiteman
- Posts: 2046
- Joined: 19 Nov 2006 16:17
- Real Name:
- Location: Drayton, Worcestershire
-
- Posts: 111
- Joined: 14 Apr 2013 21:41
- Real Name:
This should keep the wet out, but is probably only borderline breathable.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-oRQVYzgS414/U ... t+suit.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-oRQVYzgS414/U ... t+suit.jpg
It is better to be interesting rather than exact
This is my winter jacket which also is fine through spring and autumn. https://www.rapha.cc/hardshell-jacket
I cannot recommend it highly enough although it might be a slight push to pack it easily into a jersey pocket.
Fully waterproof and windproof, and relatively breathable.
Granted, it IS expensive, but you definitely get what you pay for.
Their rain jacket is also highly rated on all of the reviews I've read, and a bit more packable I think. I went for the hardshell as it's got jersey-style pockets on the back.[/url]
I cannot recommend it highly enough although it might be a slight push to pack it easily into a jersey pocket.
Fully waterproof and windproof, and relatively breathable.
Granted, it IS expensive, but you definitely get what you pay for.
Their rain jacket is also highly rated on all of the reviews I've read, and a bit more packable I think. I went for the hardshell as it's got jersey-style pockets on the back.[/url]
-
- Posts: 413
- Joined: 10 Oct 2009 13:12
- Real Name: Barry Evans
- Location: Birmingham
Just catching up with the board and spotted my name!
My jacket had turned out to be well worth the money for touring. Dry as a bone in all day hard rain, but we are not going fast. Easily packed into the back pocket. But the zip is v stiff.
I guess I'll soon find out how it breathes when pushing along on club ride.
My jacket had turned out to be well worth the money for touring. Dry as a bone in all day hard rain, but we are not going fast. Easily packed into the back pocket. But the zip is v stiff.
I guess I'll soon find out how it breathes when pushing along on club ride.
Belt up, we're going for a ride
-
- Posts: 413
- Joined: 10 Oct 2009 13:12
- Real Name: Barry Evans
- Location: Birmingham
Thanks Steve
I forgot to add that the hood I brilliant. Attaches by Velcro tab at back so you don't have to drag it with you always (e.g. when its just showers), and it pivots at the back allowing freedom of movement.
Stomped up a hill in rain yesterday and -yes- it was hot inside, but it's still 20oC here in the S France
I forgot to add that the hood I brilliant. Attaches by Velcro tab at back so you don't have to drag it with you always (e.g. when its just showers), and it pivots at the back allowing freedom of movement.
Stomped up a hill in rain yesterday and -yes- it was hot inside, but it's still 20oC here in the S France
Belt up, we're going for a ride